Berlinski's Dismantlement of Darwinism "A Virtuoso Recital" - Evolution News & Views

Evolution News and Views (ENV) provides original reporting and analysis about the debate over intelligent design and evolution, including breaking news about scientific research.

Evolution News and Views
Evolution NEWS

Berlinski's Dismantlement of Darwinism "A Virtuoso Recital"

David Berlinski's collection of essays, The Deniable Darwin, garnered a favorable review over at Hot Air, where CK Macleod had this to say:

The Deniable Darwin collects essays written from 1996 to 2009 mostly on the same general theme: That the insufferable pretensions and aggressive self-certainty of science ideologues prevent us from justly appreciating how much we actually have learned about the natural world, and how wonderfully little that is. He applies his dauntingly well-informed, remorselessly cogent skepticism to several fields of study -- theoretical physics, mathematics, linguistics, molecular biology -- but it's his dismantlement of Darwinism that he takes to center stage for a virtuoso recital.

Macleod understands that critics of Berlinski are wrong to accuse him "of the thought-crime of religious faith":

The most you can say about Berlinski's argument on this score -- the argument he actually makes as opposed to the one he's frequently assumed to be making -- is that it points, insistently, to obviously "design-like" aspects of the natural world that no biologist has been able to explain except by childlike inferences, circular reasoning, and "just-so" stories -- how this, that, or the other biological peculiarity might/must have served a survival purpose -- and by scandalously oversold pseudo-experiments.

Read the review here, and pick up your copy of The Deniable Darwin if you haven't already.