The New Scientist may sound like a scholarly science publication, but in covering news it often revels in uninformed and unprofessional attacks on critics of Darwinian evolution. So it is somewhat of a surprise to see the publication produce a not-so-veiled pan of The Greatest Show on Earth, Richard Dawkins’ new book. If the evident disappointment expressed by science filmmaker Randy Olson is at all valid, Dawkins’ resemblance to the creator of the original “Greatest Show on Earth,” 19th Century circus entrepreneur P.T. Barnum, is confirmed.

Dawkins doesn’t address his real adversaries. He simply ignores Stephen Meyer, whose Signature in the Cell is now leading the science book parade in several Amazon categories. He just dubs opponents creationist reactionaries and assumes that his haughty air will delight his claque and daunt everyone else. He has plenty of ringmaster bluster left, but nothing much to say.
Reviewer Olson, a relentless Darwinist himself, has to complain of Dawkins, “Implying that your audience is stupid does not qualify as a great new angle.”
Dawkins not only refuses to debate the likes of Stephen Meyer, he doesn’t even take note of answers to his classic arguments. For example, watch this clip, “Climbing Mt. Improbable,” from the newly released film, Darwin’s Dilemma. It’s a fine take-down of Dawkins’ case for the nearly unlimited power of natural selection.
P.T. Barnum’s famously asserted, “There’s a sucker born every minute.” C. R. Dawkins must be hoping that the suckers still will buy his books.
This article cross-posted from Discovery Blog.